“What? Why didn’t you call the police?”
“I meant to. But he’s been crying, needing formula, diapers — there’s been no time. I figured I’d get to it. Listen, I’m exhausted. You must be too. Let’s sleep and talk about it tomorrow.”
Vanessa stared at him, stunned. “You’re kidding me.”
“Please,” he said gently, walking back toward the bedroom. “We’ll figure it out in the morning.”
Left with more questions than answers, Vanessa reluctantly followed him and climbed into bed, her mind spinning. Despite everything, she fell asleep quicker than expected — drained from travel, confusion, and a million swirling suspicions.
7:03 a.m.
Muffled voices.
Vanessa stirred awake to the sound of a woman talking.
“Eric, you have to tell her. You can’t keep lying.”
“I will, I promise,” Eric replied. “I just… want the DNA results first.”
Vanessa sat up, heart pounding. DNA? Tell who what? And who the hell was this woman?
She crept toward the living room…
…and stopped cold in the hallway.
A tall woman with auburn hair stood by the kitchen table, holding a folder. Her tone was firm but laced with worry.
“You said you’d tell her as soon as she came back.”
“I didn’t expect her back last night,” Eric said quietly, rubbing the back of his neck. “It’s complicated, Jenna.”
See more on the next page
Jenna? Vanessa had never heard that name before.
She stepped into the room, arms folded tightly. “Morning,” she said icily.
Eric and Jenna both jumped.
“Vanessa,” Eric stammered, “I was going to—”
“Tell me?” she cut him off. “Tell me what? That you’ve been secretly meeting with a woman while I was out of town? That there’s a baby in our house and a paternity test in the works?”
Jenna sighed. “I’m not who you think I am.”
“Oh, really? Then who are you?” Vanessa snapped.
“I’m… Eric’s half-sister,” Jenna said slowly. “We didn’t know about each other until last year. Our biological father passed away and left us both a letter. It explained everything. He gave Eric up to the system, but kept me.”
Vanessa blinked, thrown completely off balance. “Half-sister?”
Eric nodded. “It’s true. I didn’t want to bring it up until I was sure. We only met face to face a few months ago.”
“And the baby?” Vanessa asked, still tense.
Jenna swallowed. “He’s mine.”
Eric added quickly, “Her ex-boyfriend abandoned them. She couldn’t handle everything on her own and needed a place to stay while sorting out custody and support stuff. I told her she could stay for a few days.”
“I didn’t expect you to come back early,” he added, almost apologetically.
Vanessa glanced between the two of them. Her heartbeat still hadn’t returned to normal.
“So you lied. You said someone left the baby on the doorstep.”
Eric looked down, ashamed. “I panicked. I thought it would sound… better than ‘I’ve been hiding my long-lost sister and her baby from you for three weeks.’”
Vanessa stared at them, her mind spinning. She should’ve been furious. And yet… beneath the betrayal and confusion, something else tugged at her — curiosity. Sadness. A strange sense of empathy.
She looked at the baby, now cooing softly in the living room bassinet.
“Why didn’t you just tell me the truth?” she whispered.
“I was afraid you’d think I had a secret family,” Eric said. “Or that I didn’t trust you. But I do, Vanessa. I just… didn’t know how.”
Vanessa sighed and sank into a chair. “I don’t know what hurts more — the lie, or the fact that you didn’t trust me with something this big.”
There was a heavy silence.
Finally, she looked up.
“I want a real conversation. No more hiding. No more ‘I’ll explain later.’ Tonight. You, me, and everything laid bare.”
Eric nodded solemnly. “Tonight. I promise.”
Vanessa glanced again at the baby, who looked up at her with wide, curious eyes.
This isn’t what she expected to come home to.
But somehow, she sensed — this was only the beginning..
